What Is It About the DSA and Amazon, Anyway?

Nov 20, 2026 7:20 PM
Advertisement
What Is It About the DSA and Amazon, Anyway?
AP Photo/David Zalubowski

To be honest, that's a dumb question, but I ask it anyway because it is instructive. We all know why socialists hate Amazon: it's run by a billionaire, makes a ton of money, employs a lot of low-skill, low-wage workers who want more money, and it makes all our lives better despite the government. 

Advertisement

What's not to hate? 

I first took note of AOC as a serious problem when she managed to drive an Amazon warehouse expansion out of her district. 

It was pure AOC: since Amazon wasn't going to pay extortionate wages for low-skill labor, better to have no jobs or economic development at all. 

Keep the poor on welfare rather than helping them develop skills and build up an employment history, getting on the first rung of the economic ladder. It is the socialist way, at least with their clients. With the people who create things? It's their job to give it up. 

What's striking about Mamdani's tweet — the underlying issue I will discuss in a bit — is that it gets things backward. Amazon is a multi-trillion-dollar company (whose stock, no doubt, is a major part of New York's and New York City's pension investment portfolio) because it works hard not to be pillaged by everyone, and because it provides a service people value quite a bit. 

As a hermit, I get a lot of stuff delivered by Amazon, and I would wager that most of you do too. In fact, one of the crimes we all complain about these days is porch piracy, because they have made a business of stealing those Amazon deliveries since everybody uses the service. Amazon is a target because they do their business well. 

Advertisement

As with any business, Amazon isn't perfect, but people wouldn't shop with them if they weren't generally superior to the alternatives, including in price. 

That makes Amazon a rich target. Amazon has something, so socialists want it. 

Now the issue: Amazon employs many small delivery services and gig workers, and the Teamsters and the socialists want to consolidate all of that into one Amazon delivery service that can be unionized and organized. No more little guys; everybody becomes an employee of the big company. 

You would think that the socialists would be for the little guy, but the opposite is true. It's like saying that having the state own the means of production is anti-monopoly; it's the opposite. The big guys are easier to control, and gig workers are left out in the cold, as happened in California when they essentially banned gig work. Controlling one big thing is easier than corralling lots of individuals and small companies. 

Amazon is ramping up a pressure campaign opposing a controversial labor bill in New York City – as speculation grows that the City Council could vote on the pro-worker legislation as soon as next month, The Post has learned.

On Thursday, Amazon began appealing directly to its Big Apple customers in its fight against the Delivery Protection Act, also known as Intro 518 – warning shoppers in messaging on its website and app that they could be charged up to $5 more per order if the bill is passed, as The Post first reported. 

Proponents of the bill, which include the Teamsters, are pushing for the vote to happen before the end of the year. There are only two more scheduled meetings on the City Council calendar this year, on Dec. 3 and Dec. 17.

A super majority of council members and Mayor Zohran Mamdani support the bill and have been demanding that the Speaker call for a vote. The bill would end Amazon’s reliance on subcontractors and force Amazon to directly hire its delivery workers – and it’s not clear whether the final bill will include a direct-hire mandate despite the Speaker’s public remarks about wanting to preserve jobs.

In addition to Amazon, companies including FedEx would be subject to the new rules.

Advertisement

There are many reasons a company like Amazon or FedEx hires subcontractors, not least because their businesses are cyclical. Christmas season is heavy; other times less so. If you hire a set number of employees, especially when they inevitably get unionized, as is the intent here, you end up with a bunch of people on the payroll when you don't need them. 

And, of course, there are a lot of reasons why gig workers want to be gig workers. They don't want to work for a big company, want to do it as a side job, are between jobs, or have a poor employment record. Who knows? Ask your Uber driver why they do it. 

Socialists hate that. They want things centralized, and if it costs "big companies" (read: you and me, actually) more, so be it. When prices go up, the politicians and socialists just blame greed. 

Advertisement

Greed. First of all, at some level, greed is a universal, not a variable. Most people want more. 

Second, the whole pitch of the DSA and the Teamsters is greed: stick with us, and we will take from them and give it to you!

So spare me the slogans. Mamdani has built his political career on promising "free stuff" paid for by the big bad guys. Give to people who have done nothing to earn it and take it from the people who usually have. 

I don't have any particular love for Jeff Bezos, but it really is striking to me how people justify stealing from him in one way or another. Last year I wrote about the trend of wealthy liberals who were proud to shoplift from Whole Foods because Bezos owned it. The New York Times even wrote about "microlooting" by, I kid you not, wealthy magazine writers and professionals taking a stand for economic justice by stealing from Whole Foods. 

That's not greed. It's JUSTICE!

Mamdani's tweet is so precious to me for the same reason I made fun of that socialist professor earlier today: it completely misunderstands why good things get created, and focuses solely on how to steal them when they are created. 

Advertisement

That's socialism in a nutshell. When you see something good, loot it until it is destroyed, and blame capitalism. 

Editor's Note: The Democrat Party has been infected by socialism, and it's spreading FAST. Democrats are claiming there's nothing to worry about, but we know the truth.

Help us continue to shine a light on the socialist takeover by joining HotAir VIP.  Use promo code FIGHT to get 60% off your VIP membership.

Comments

VIP

Join the Conversation

VIP members get the ability to comment on articles.

Recommended

Trending on HotAir Videos