Horrible Story of the Day

Nov 18, 2026 9:20 PM
Advertisement
Horrible Story of the Day
AP Photo/Jose Luis Magana, File

It can't be anything but horrible because this story starts with a severed head wrapped in a trash bag. 

On September 28, 2022, a woman walking her dog in Foresthill, California, which is northeast of Sacramento, discovered the remains. Despite the shocking nature of the discovery, it didn't make much news at the time because there was a massive wildfire burning in the area. That fire, called the Mosquito Fire, turned out to be the largest wildfire in the state that year. It eventually burned 76,788 acres, which is roughly 120 square miles.

Advertisement

But behind the scenes, the police were working the case. 

The victim went unidentified for years, as investigators failed to connect the remains to a known missing persons case. Officials conducted an autopsy, developed an age and race profile, commissioned an artist rendering based on his skull and entered his DNA into a national database but still came up empty, they said. 

In January 2024, investigators sent the victim’s DNA out for forensic generic genealogy testing to Texas-based Othram Labs, officials said in a press statement. The biotechnology company, which specializes in DNA testing to solve cold cases, “developed a genealogical profile that helped identify possible distant relatives of the victim,” officials said. 

With the assistance of the FBI, investigators used this information to track down a family tree, interviewing relatives and obtaining additional DNA samples for comparison.

The victim was finally identified as Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr. And the reason the case had never been connected to any missing persons cases in the area is that Fitzmaurice's wife and daughter were still pretending he was alive.

The women "kept up the facade to family and friends that Paul was still alive," Placer County Sheriff Wayne Woo said at a news conference Wednesday. He said they continued receiving Fitzmaurice’s Social Security benefits and California public pension after his death.

Woo said the women told some of Fitzmaurice’s estranged relatives "he was being a recluse, and he would disappear for days at a time." 

They claimed he "would come back to the house every week or so and stay for a couple of days," Woo said.

Advertisement

Police haven't confirmed that stealing that money was the motive in this case, but that's how it looks at the moment. Police did make it clear they believe his adult daughter Mary Fitzmaurice killed him and then convinced her mother to help her hide the body. 

Investigators believe that Mary was responsible for Paul’s murder at the Citrus Heights home on Lichen Drive, and Gwenn helped dispose of his remains.

Both were arrested on Tuesday as Placer County Sheriff's Office detectives served a search warrant at the Citrus Heights home.

Mary was booked on murder charges, while Gwenn was booked on accessory charges. More charges may be coming, officials said.

Maybe there's more to this story but it's hard to imagine a scenario where any of this is innocent. Fitzmaurice was 73 at the time he was killed, so it's also a bit hard to imagine him being a real physical threat at that age. But who knows. It's a horrible story and we probably haven't heard all the horrible parts of it yet. In fact, there's at least one grisly question that hasn't been answered yet. The head was found about 30 miles from the house where the three of them once lived. The rest of the remains have not been located yet. Apparently no one knows what happened to the body.

Here are the mugshots of the two women:

Advertisement

And here's a bit of Sheriff Woo describing the case yesterday.

Editor’s Note: The American people overwhelmingly support President Trump’s law and order agenda.

Help us fight back against the Democrats and Soros-backed DAs that refuse to enforce our laws to hold criminals accountable. Join HotAir VIP and use promo code FIGHT to receive 60% off your membership.

News Topics CALIFORNIA | CRIME | FBI

Comments

VIP

Join the Conversation

VIP members get the ability to comment on articles.

Recommended

Trending on HotAir Videos